Last week in this space, I reviewed film on the top quarterback prospects of the 2017 class and shared my notes with you. Today, we are going to look at the top three RBs – all of which are likely to be drafted in the 1st Round. In my first batch of mock draft analysis, I supposed that we might even see a fourth RB taken in the 1st Round – Joe Mixon and Wayne Gallman will have to wait for their film review but keep them on the radar.
Before the combine, I only came across one mock draft with Dalvin Cook placed above Fournette. I’m not sure if that was a publicity stunt or a true belief at the time but it seems to be the vogue opinion now. I’m not there yet, but it is getting very close the more tape I watch. I decided to cherry pick the film I watched of Fournette because I wanted to see him against good competition. I chose to watch him play against Wisconsin (#4 rushing defense in the nation) and against Ole Miss (#22 and one of only four teams to give up single digit rushing TDs, 3 of which came from Fournette himself). In my opinion, Fournette reminds me of Adrian Peterson. He is big but still possesses enough breakaway speed if he hits the hole and can rip off some huge runs. On the downside though, he has a lot of carries for little to no gain that can keep the offense behind the chains. I think he is an underrated receiver out of the backfield (as evidenced by a beautiful wheel route catch he made against Wisconsin). He is also decent in pass protection which I was not expecting (in the two games he was actively engaged in pass protection 18 times by my count – he blew 4 of them that led to a sack/pressure/hurry).
Let’s look closer at his boom or bust potential. In those two games I watched, Fournette had 38 carries. On 16 of those 38 carries he earned 3 yards or less – that’s a whopping 42%. You may be able to find similar stats for any running back but it’s a bit worrisome for somebody who is likely going to be drafted in the Top 5 of the NFL Draft. At that rate, of 3 yards or less, he is putting his offense in 3rd and Medium or 3rd and Long situations too often. Throughout the film I watched, I was struck by how infrequently Fournette actually breaks tackles. On his three TD runs against Ole Miss he was essentially untouched for the combined 200+ yards of those plays. If he hits the hole just right, he has a combination of vision and speed to kill the defense but he does not often gain extra yards by breaking tackles. If I am going to harp on his bad runs, I do also need to give credit for his great runs. In addition to all of those short runs he also had runs of 19, 24, 30, 59, 76 and 78. Remember, that is just in two games against good defenses and ultimately that is why he will be the first RB drafted.
At the combine, Fournette weighed in as the heaviest RB at 240lb (the next heaviest was 233lb). It should not be surprising then that his 40 yard dash time was far from elite (4.51 seconds, 20th out of 31) and his vertical jump was horrendous (dead last). I hate to use the cliche, but he very well may be the guy who runs better in pads. Honestly, I was disappointed by his two drills and I would have liked to see him complete the others to have more points of comparison. I still have Fournette as RB1, but it is much closer than when I started my research two weeks ago.
In my notes, I wrote that if Dalvin Cook showed up at the combine and weighed in at 215lb, he would automatically be my RB1 and overtake Leonard Fournette. His game tape is that explosive. He weighed in just short of my hope, at 210lb. My biggest knock on Cook right now is the diminutive size. In 2016, 29 RBs were measured at the combine and just 2 of them weighed in under 200lb. I have seen him listed anywhere between 202-213lb; for comparison, ESPN lists him at 213, CBS has him at 206 and DraftBreakdown has him at 202. I’m going to assume that he purposefully bulked up for the combine and I expect to see his playing weight fall closer to 202 than 213 come September. There’s one other thing that concerns me about Cook: his pass protection. In the two games I watched, he was in protection only a handful of times – most times he was out in the pattern. I think he has the desire to block, he ended up being the de factor lead blocker on QB scrambles a few times, but he doesn’t have the size.
When watching Cook play, it is clear immediately how explosive he is, especially his cuts. What is also evident is how patient he is, allowing his blocks to set up. He rarely takes the hole running straight, but that explosiveness and patience combine for some great runs. He dominated Florida in the first half but slowed in the second when they were trying to milk the clock. Against Michigan’s dominant defense he played well too. In my opinion, two plays against Michigan will best sum up Cook’s potential. In the 1st Quarter, there was a play where he set out wide as a WR, ran a simple go route, beat the defender and caught the ball over his shoulder for a gain of 45 yards. It was perfectly executed and could be the piece of tape that showcases his receiving skills to NFL scouts. Later in that game, in the 4th Quarter, Cook took a 3rd & 22 counter handoff, that was meant to set up better punting field position, and scampered 71 yards after breaking two tackles and turning on his breakaway speed. A last second push out of bounds was the only thing that kept him from the endzone. That play showed his patience as his blocks set up and then he exploded up field. Another positive that caught my eye was the varied sets that FSU’s offense ran. In the two games I watched, they ran multiple plays out of shotgun, pistol, single back and I formation – that’s good for his transition to the NFL.
If you look at the results of Cook’s combine performance, it throws a bit of cold water on the film. That’s why I still have him behind Fournette even though I was close to flip-flopping after watching the Michigan tape. Cook was near the worst RBs in the 3 cone drill, the shuttle drill, the broad jump and the vertical jump. His 40 yard dash time was good but not great: 4.49 which was tied for sixth fastest. The only place he really surprised me was his 22 bench press reps which was tied for third most.
Christian McCaffrey is a better football player than he is a running back. That was the conclusion that I kept returning to while taking notes as I watched film and researched his game logs and career stats. He will be drafted by a good team in the late 1st Round and will slot in immediately as a prototypical third down back. He’s good at a lot of things, but not great at any. Ultimately, I think that will limit his RSO upside in Year One but at least it will get him on the field right away.
I watched McCaffrey play against UCLA and Washington and in both games, I was impressed with his pass protection skills. He routinely picked up the blitz and frequently chipped a rusher before going out for a pass. He is a great safety valve for his quarterback and because of his blocking ability, he is a great threat to catch screen passes; he can feign blocking without the defense thinking “yeah right, he’s not blocking” and then sneak out of the backfield. His middle name very well may be Versatile because in just two games, he took three snaps at WR and five at QB (in the Wildcat, no passes). He will likely be the only player I profile this offseason that has passing, rushing, receiving and returning TDs in his career (2/21/10/2 for the record).
McCaffrey is a very patient runner at the line of scrimmage. Honestly, he was too patient at times against Washington and I think it cost him additional yardage as he let plays develop too long against Washington’s strong defense. He is rarely stopped for a loss of yardage. In fact, I noted it midway through one of the games I watched and went back to review the play-by-play: in over 38 carries in those games he had just one negative yardage run.
McCaffrey, in my opinion, is quicker than he is fast. That showed itself at the combine where he tied for the fifth fastest 40 yard dash (4.48) but did very well in the 3 cone drill (fastest) and shuttle drill (fourth fastest). His jumping stats were also above average. No surprise given his size, he was only able to do 10 bench press reps which was the second fewest.
Note: When watching film for a player, I typically pick two games at random to watch. I do not necessarily want to watch games where they did very well or very poorly as that may not be a great illustration of their true ability. If possible, when comparing players at the same position I also like to watch film against common opponents. Full disclosure, I am not watching film of every single game any player plays, instead I am looking for a representative sample. When researching college players I use a number of resources, I would recommend bookmarking the below sites…
Robert F. Cowper is a freelance writer who lives in New Jersey. Robert works as a recreation professional, specializing in youth sports, when he isn’t acting as commissioner for his many fantasy sports leagues.
Throughout the offseason, I will be...
As part of my fourth season...
We’re now less than a month...
One of the more interesting debates...
Enter the league logon and password provided in the league invitation email: