IDP Start/Sit: Week 4

Updated: September 27th 2023

 

Here we are. Week 4. Some of us are celebrating our start, others about to panic. Wherever you land in there, let’s take a breath, focus in on week 4, and find some great options for your lineup to get your team heading towards that playoff birth!

Week 3 Recap

DL:

Start: Greg Rousseau (1 sack, 1 solo) 👍

Sit: Joe Tryon-Shoyinka (2 solos) 👍

LB:

Start: Alex Anzalone (4 solos, 1 assist) 👎

Sit: Nick Bolton (Injured)

DB:

Start: Dax Hill (1 sack, 6 solos, 1 assist) 👍

Sit: Kyler Dugger (5 solos, 2 assists, 1 PBU) 👎

Week 1 Starts & Sits

START: Za’Darius Smith, Cleveland Browns, DL46 (ED33)

The Cleveland Browns have one of the best defenses to kick off the 2023 season. While Myles Garrett has been on a tear, Smith has been quite productive in his own right, while it has not fully come through on the box score, yet.

He has 9 pressures and 4 QB hits on 73 pass rush snaps. While this has not netted a sack yet, this matchup in week 4 against the Baltimore Ravens. We targeted the Ravens matchup in week 1 for Will Anderson, and for the same reasons, we are doing it again. Lamar has an average time to throw of 2.82 seconds. This matchup along with Smith’s success winning his matchups up front, with a very strong 27.3% win rate in true pass rush sets. This looks like a great week for Za’Darius to notch his first sack of the season.

SIT: Rashan Gary, Green Bay Packers, DL25 (ED20)

Gary has done an amazing job coming back from a very serious injury last season and has already shown us what we saw in his limited breakout campaign last season before getting hurt. 4 sacks through his first 3 games, how could we “sit” Gary? Well, in comes the Detroit Lions on Thursday night with one of the best offensive lines in the NFL and an offense that appreciates a run/pass balance and focuses on getting the ball out of Goff’s hands (2.56 seconds for his time to throw).

These matchup concerns and a short week for the Packers’ defense could be better and make Gary a bit of a risk to play as a DL2 for me. He is already a limited participant from his own injury, but the potential downgrades across the rest of the defense (Campbell and Jaire) don’t help the overall case either. Gary has the talent to deliver for a lineup still, but I am planning for a bit of down week.

START: Alex Singleton, Denver Broncos, LB48

The “King of Tackle Efficiency” has not worn his crown this year while only logging a slightly above-average tackle efficiency of 13.33%. This week, against the Bears, the Broncos linebackers should find a nice bounce-back game as opposing linebackers have had top-10 performances against the Chicago Bears. Also, Josey Jewell is no guarantee for this matchup either experiencing a groin injury that took him out of week 3.

Singleton has a chance to take the lead role this week against a hapless offense and find a way back on top of the tackle efficiency hill… or at the very least, be a strong top 30 LB play for us in week 4 of our IDP seasons!

SIT: Tremaine Edmunds, Chicago Bears, LB20

Tremaine Edmunds has seen some heat this season from Chicago fans since his big contract this off-season and the lack of a good start from either side of the ball for the Bears. Edmunds has been very effective as a tackler, with one of the best seasons in his career, at 16.04% tackle efficiency. So why bench or fade Edmunds this week?

This comes down to the matchup and opportunity. Edmunds saw his snap count dip a bit last week and with no clear injury or understanding at this time from the coach, this is a little concerning. And for the Denver Broncos, opposing LBs have not fared as well for IDP against them. In fact, they are bottom 5 in points given up to LBs. For these reasons, I am passing on Edmunds as an LB2 this week. 

START: Rudy Ford, Green Bay Packers, DB46 (S43)

Last season, Rudy Ford was an afterthought at the start of the 2022 season. But by the end, and going into 2023, Ford was the presumed starter for a solid Packers defense and has found a way to be successful for IDP in this new role.

He has notched 20 tackles on 212 defensive snaps. Along with 2 PBUs Rudy Ford has a decent start to the IDP season. His alignment and usage have been good, but not great as well. Taking 49.05% of his snaps within the sweet spot (DL, Box, Slot) alignments, he has made the most and gets a team in the Detroit Lions, that are top 10 in scoring for opposing teams’ safeties. And with Sam LaPorta off to a hot start and Goff’s tendency to target inside the numbers, Ford is in line for a much better performance than anticipated for week 4.

SIT: Tyrann Mathieu, New Orleans Saints, DB36 (S35)

Tyrann has played an ideal role with strong alignment in the sweet spot at, 57.9% of his snaps. However, he has had mediocre delivery for IDP with this usage. 12 total tackles on 202 snaps, 1 pass break-up, and only 2 pass rush opportunities. The under-performance for the first 3 weeks has me a bit concerned about his ability to deliver in this next matchup against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

The Bucs have been a bottom-half IDP scoring team for opposing safeties and looked to have been a bit exposed against the Eagles in week 3. Getting pressure on Mayfield and getting him out of the pocket has led to less success and shorter drives, which can limit our IDP upside as well.

For this week, I am out on Mathieu and I would be wary for the remainder of the season as well.

More Analysis by Jake

IDP Sit/Start: Week 11

Updated: November 17th 2022

Week 11? That just feels weird to say! We are a few short weeks away from most fantasy football playoffs and hopefully, you are all either locked in for the playoffs or still alive in the hunt for it. Regardless, let’s try and get your IDP lineups set the best and maybe find some value for our rosters too!
As a friendly reminder, the rankings I show for them are what is the ECR over from Fantasy Pros for this week.

WEEK 10 RECAP
DL:
Start: Jeffery Simmons (3 solos, 1 assist, PD. Not bad for a non-sack game!)
Start: Josh Paschal (injured during the game, got a zero, played 17 snaps)

Sit: Uchenna Nwosu (1 assist. This isn’t a sell for the ROS, just wasn’t a good matchup)


LB:

Start: Blake Martinez / Luke Masterson (Masterson stats: 2 solos, 4 assists, TFL, 72% snaps. Not a great week but could have some value as an LB3/4 moving forward)

Start: Willie Gay Jr. (6 solos, 2 assists, sack, QB hit, PD)

Sit: Bobby Okereke (6 solos, 3 assists, PD. Bobby got 100% snaps with Leonard not suiting up.)

 

DB:
Start: Duron Harmon (2 solos, 2 assists)

Start: Jalen Ramsey (5 solos, assist)

Sit: Justin Simmons (Was inactive for the game late in the week)

 

START: Alex HighsmithPittsburgh Steelers, DL33

Alex Highsmith has been more of a volume play this season, delivering average numbers. 68.8 PFF pass-rush grade on the season, a 7.5% pressure rate over his last 3 games, but continues to see high snap numbers every week, 87% for the entire season! Last week, Highsmith had a strong week last week (2 sacks, 5 total tackles, QB hit) and we are not just chasing the points here. Highsmith gets a favorable matchup with the Bengals who are allowing a 24% pressure rate and a 21% sack conversion rate! These numbers are slightly inflated from week 1 (7 sacks) and week 2 (6 sacks), but the Bengals are still allowing 2.7 sacks per game since then. Along with Highsmith’s consistent effort and favorable matchup, TJ Watt is supposed to be back into action which should only allow Highsmith to operate with less attention and give him a better chance to deliver overall IDP production for us. He should be considered at a solid DL2 option this week.

START: Denico AutryTennessee Titans, DL34

Denico Autry has capitalized on injuries to his teammates and his increased role. He has delivered a whopping 23 pressures over the last 3 games along with his snap counts jumping up in week 9 (76 snaps) and week 10 (52 snaps), his two highest snap counts of the year so far. But his success is not just recent either, he has a 13.7% pressure rate on the year and a very good PFF pass-rush grade of 76.7. This week he gets the Green Bay Packers who are middle of the “pack” (dad joke achieved!) with their lower pressure rate at 22% but higher sack conversion rate at 18%. The Packers have begun to shift up their passing attack the last few weeks too which bodes well for the Titan’s pass rush. Rodgers has seen his time to throw be the highest 3 weeks out of their last 4. And his last two weeks Rodgers’ Average Depth of Target (ADOT) is the highest it’s been all season, by over a full yard from his previous high. These longer throws and longer time-to-throw give Autry a better chance to get home for some big plays this week. Autry should be a strong DL2 play this week.

SIT: Khalil Mack, Los Angeles Chargers, DL20

Khalil Mack has struggled to make a consistent impact for the Chargers defense recently outside of his big strip of the ball from Drake London against the Falcons. Khalil has managed only 3 pressures over the past three weeks, while maintaining a strong snap count. The IDP production in the run game that prime Mack would deliver is a ghost of its former self. He has only topped 3 combined tackles twice in his 9 full games this season. This week Mack gets the Kansas City Chiefs who have the lowest sack conversion rate in the NFL at 4%. This is due in large part to the play of Patrick Mahomes and his pocket presence and escapability, but this severely limits Macks already low upside. Play Mack feels like you are playing him based solely on past production and I wouldn’t consider him more than a low-end DL3 for this week.

START: Fankie LuvuCarolina Panthers, LB27

Frankie got back to IDP prominence last week with a big game! The big takeaway though is Frankie is back to 100% snap share alongside Shaq Thompson. This 2-LB look is what we want to watch and see if this really is the case for the rest of the season. This week, Frankie gets the Ravens and this is a plus matchup for him. The Ravens run the most plays per game in the NFL at 69.7 plays and the teams that have found success at slowing down the Ravens’ offense has been pressure/blitzing. Frankie has seen consistent pass-rush snaps and has been successful with a 70.3 PFF pass-rush grade. I anticipate this is how the Panthers will try to slow him down and Luvu will be a part of this. My biggest concern is Luvu does have 16 missed tackles on the season and getting after Lamar who is one of the most elusive runners in the NFL, might mean some missed opportunities too. But I would fire up Luvu as a high-end LB2 this week.

START: Jamin DavisWashington Commanders, LB32

This pick of Jamin Davis feels like the least “sexy” pick of a start that I have ever made. Jamin Davis was a first-round talent that hasn’t quite fully delivered or been able to climb past Cole Holcomb on the Commanders’ depth chart. With Holcomb out, however, Davis finds himself with 100% snap share now and Holcomb looks unlikely to play this week (he was a “Did Not Practice”, DNP, this Wednesday). His matchup against Houston this week finds him a run-heavy situation where Dameon Pierce has been seeing plenty of work with 15+ rushes the last 5 weeks, and 3 of those at 20+ even with 4 of those being losses and negative game scripts. Davis doesn’t feel like a strong play rest of the season, but for this week he is a solid LB2.

SIT: Zaven Collins, Arizona Cardinals, LB21

I am a huge Zaven Collins fan myself (NFL and IDP) but this week, I am struggling to see him as an LB2 this week even as a true 3-down LB with 100% snap share. However, not all snaps are created equal and Zaven is starting to get a small dose of the “Micah Parsons experience” and seeing more snaps from the DL position. Last week was 36% of his snaps at DL and week 8 was 31%. During those weeks he saw his lowest tackle production both weeks with 4 combined tackles in each of them. But if he is lining up at DL and taking pass-rush snaps, doesn’t he have more big play upside then? While that is a possibility, the matchup this week against San Francisco is less than ideal. They have the lowest pressure rate in the NFL and 7th best sack conversion rate allowed. I would steer away from Zaven unless you really need him in an LB3/4 spot due to his volume, but if you can afford to bench him for a week, I’d do it.

START: Dane BeltonNew York Giants, DB77

Dane Belton came into the season with some real promise as a rookie, but Belton experienced a broken collarbone, and Julian Love and Xavier McKinney ran with the starting safety jobs. In a strange turn of events, Xavier McKinney broke his hand and ended up on IR and Belton got the chance. The real surprise was Belton taking over the bulk of the “sweet spot” snaps (Box, DL, or Slot). He had 67% of them this last week. This only turned out to be 4 combined tackles, but with snap alignments like this, he could be a late-season steal off your waiver wire. This may only be for the next few weeks, but during that time Belton should be a high-end DB3 to maybe even a low-end DB2.

START: Tyrann MathieuNew Orleans Saints, DB26

Tyrann Mathieu has been one of the few IDPs that have been able to play every snap so far this season, which is impressive in its own rights. This last week changed we saw a heavy shift for Tyrann though with Pete Werner out there was a heavy shift to have Mathieu in the box. He saw 76% of his snaps in the “sweet spot”!! This is an extreme amount for any safety and as such, with Werner likely out again this week, we need to fire up Mathieu against the LA Rams. This usage led to his highest tackle output of the season and playing the Rams will lend to some strong opportunities for big-play upside as well. Tyrann is looking like a DB1 this week and smash start!!

SIT: Kyle Dugger, New England Patriots, DB27

Kyle Dugger had an amazing 2021 for IDP production and did so with strong efficiency numbers on lower snap numbers than other IDP producers around him. He had a strong tackle efficiency of 11.9% last year but this year he has seen a dip of almost 2 points down to 9.3%. The biggest concern though is he is still at a limited snap count though as well as battling injuries this year. With a heavy rotation at the safety spot for the Patriots between Dugger, Phillips, Peppers, and McCourty, and the return from his most recent ankle injury, Dugger needs to stay on our benches until he proves consistent production.

More Analysis by Jake